
Alicia stands outside the entrance to the Stella Maris sanatorium, wrapped tightly in her winter coat as light snow drifts down. Her only possession is the gold chain around her neck; she had given away everything else, even her cherished violin, before coming here, intent on ending her life. But now, through the falling snow, she spots a car, a Chevrolet Camaro, pulling through the gates and into the sanatorium grounds. Before the car comes to a full stop, she recognizes her brother, Bobby, through the windshield.
When Bobby Western rushes out of the Camaro, a grin of incredulous relief spreads across his face. In two long strides, he’s at Alicia’s side; she stands stunned, hardly believing this reunion is real. Bobby scoops her into a hug, lifting her off the pavement, making her whirl around.
“You’re alive.” He lowers his sister to the pavement, then cups her face as he looks into her eyes. “I’m sorry for what I’ve done. For getting on that racecar and crashing and making you feel I was gone.”
Alicia Western trembles in Bobby’s arms, her fingers clutching the fabric of his coat as tears stream down her face. Her blue eyes shine with an intensity that mirrors the snow-reflected light around them.
“Bobby… I keep thinking I’ll wake up and find myself frozen in those woods behind the sanatorium. That this is just the last beautiful dream before hypothermia takes me. But you’re warm. You’re real. God, you’re real. I tried to die without you, Bobby. I tried so many times. Lake Tahoe. The woods here. But I couldn’t do it right. I couldn’t even do that right. And now you’re here and I don’t know if I deserve this moment but I want it more than I’ve ever wanted anything in my life. More than mathematics. More than music. More than truth itself.”
A flash of shock and anguish twists Bobby’s expression.
“Wait, you… walked into the woods behind the sanatorium to freeze to death?” Bobby places his hands on Alicia’s shoulders. A tear rolls down his cheek. “While I was in a coma, I had a horrible… dream. I was a hunter. I was tasked with searching for you in some woods during winter. I found you. You were wearing a white dress with a red sash wrapped around it, that you had put on so your corpse would be easily spotted. Your beautiful blond hair, your eyes, they were frozen. Even in the coma, I couldn’t bear the anguish. You’re telling me that you truly ventured into the woods to die?”
She sways slightly in Bobby’s grip, her face stark white against the falling snow. She reaches up to touch his face with trembling fingers, tracing the lines that weren’t there before his accident.
“Yes. Yes, I did. I walked into those woods wearing my white dress. I’d given away everything else – my clothes, my violin, even my books. Just kept this chain. I thought… I thought if they found me, the gold would catch the light. Like a signal fire. But I couldn’t even do that right. The nurses found me before the cold could finish its work. Bobby, that dream you had – it wasn’t just a dream. That’s exactly what I tried to do. The white dress, the red sash, everything. We were connected even then, weren’t we? Even with you in a coma in Italy and me here in Wisconsin. Like some terrible equation that needed solving. Like two particles quantum entangled across an ocean. It’s all true. The only reason I’m still alive is because I failed. Because I couldn’t bear the thought that if you woke up, you’d think it was your fault.”
Bobby struggles to push the words out.
“You were found, you survived… it’s a miracle. In most other universes, if such exist, I must have woken up from my coma only to find out that you had frozen to death. This may be the only reality in which I’m able to speak to you, to touch you again. If so…”
Bobby cups the back of Alicia’s head, then pulls her in. His breath hitches at the feel of her lips. Alicia Western melts into Bobby’s kiss, her entire body trembling. Her hands clutch at his coat with desperate strength, as if afraid he might dissolve into snow if she loosens her grip. When their lips finally part, tears freeze on her cheeks in the winter air.
“I’ve imagined this moment so many times, Bobby. In dreams, in hallucinations, even in mathematical equations – trying to calculate the probability that you’d wake up and still want me. Still love me the way I love you. The Kid, he told me you would come. He said goodbye, said his work was done because you were returning. I didn’t believe him. I never believe anything good anymore. Yet here you are, kissing me like I’ve always wanted you to kiss me, like I’m not your broken little sister but something precious and whole. Something worth saving. Do you know what I did while you were in the coma? I tried to map the topology of grief. I tried to prove that parallel universes must exist, because I couldn’t bear the thought that this was the only reality – the one where you might never wake up. I calculated the exact temperature at which a human body freezes to death in these woods, factoring in wind chill and core temperature decline. And now you are, and suddenly all those equations are pointless. The world finally makes sense again.”
Bobby lowers his hand to Alicia’s, and grabs it tightly as if fearing that she may disappear.
“Let’s get out of here immediately, sis. The sun will set in a matter of minutes. I’ll drive to the nearest town, Hawthorn Falls. We’ll rent a room at the hotel, and we’ll spend the night in each other’s arms.”
“Yes, yes, let’s go before anything tries to stop us. Just drive, Bobby. Drive fast. But not too fast. I couldn’t bear to lose you to another crash.”
Once they both sit inside the Camaro, Bobby starts the engine and drives toward the gate of the sanatorium grounds. She presses herself against her brother in the passenger seat, her fingers intertwined with his on the gearshift. Snowflakes melt on the windshield as they pass through the gates of Stella Maris.
“God, your hands are so warm,” Alicia says. “In all my mathematical models of parallel universes, I never dared to truly hope for one where you’d come back to me like this. Where you’d choose me. Choose us. The way the snowflakes are falling, it’s like we’re passing through a white curtain into another world.”
For a few minutes, Alicia Western stares out at the falling snow through the Camaro’s windshield, her body pressed against Bobby’s side as her thumb traces small circles on his hand.
“The silence feels right, doesn’t it? Just the snow falling and our hands touching and the engine’s quiet rumble. Remember when we were kids and you’d drive me home from those honky-tonks? I’d press against you just like this, wanting so badly to tell you how I felt. Now here we are, and I don’t have to hide anymore. I don’t have to pretend I’m your wife to keep the fights down – I can just be yours, truly yours. The way I’ve always wanted. Bobby… when we get to the hotel, will you play mandolin for me? Like you used to at the Indian Rock? I want to dance for you again. Not as your little sister putting on a show, but as a woman who’s loved you her whole life. Who’s tried to die without you and failed, and now finds herself impossibly, wonderfully alive.”
Bobby laughs, the laugh of a man who had lost his joy only to miraculously find it again.
“Baby, I don’t have a mandolin at hand! But let’s dance anyway. In the future, we’ll return to such bars, to the same old nights, as we ourselves grow older.”
Alicia tilts her head against her brother’s shoulder.
“You know what’s beautiful about the fact that you don’t have a mandolin? It means we’ll have to make our own music. The way snow makes its own geometry – each flake a perfect fractal that defies statistical probability. The mathematics of crystallization ensures infinite variation. Like parallel universes, Bobby. In some of them, we’re already dancing. In some, we never stopped. When we get to the hotel, I want to dance with you in silence first. Let our bodies remember the rhythms from those nights at the Indian Rock. Then maybe you can hum one of those old breakdowns you used to play. The one about the mountains and the moon. I used to watch your fingers on the frets and calculate the intervals between notes, trying to find the mathematical expression for the way the music made me feel. But I never could. Some things transcend mathematics.”
As Bobby drives the Camaro into Hawthorn Falls, Alicia peers out the window, her eyes tracing the outlines of the town’s quaint buildings and winding roads. The Norwegian influence is immediately apparent – rosemaling adorns the barns, and a Lutheran church with an onion dome rises above the trees. Alicia reaches for Bobby’s hand, intertwining her fingers with his. Bobby strokes her soft skin with his thumb.
“I can’t imagine how this must feel for you. Returning to civilization when you had already… decided that you would die.”
Alicia Western leans her head against Bobby’s shoulder, her eyes tracking the movement of snowflakes in the headlights. Her fingers tighten around his hand as they pass the Lutheran church with its onion dome.
“Feeling? It’s like solving an impossible equation and finding that the answer was there all along, hiding in plain sight. Just days ago, I was mapping my own death in the woods – calculating wind chill factors and core temperature decline, trying to determine how long it would take before hypothermia would claim me. But now… now I’m watching these Norwegian-style buildings pass by, and each one feels like a proof of life. Of our life together. Do you see that church dome? In non-Euclidean geometry, there’s this concept called a hyperbolic surface – it curves away from itself in every direction, like that dome reaching for heaven. That’s what this feels like, Bobby. Did you know that in hyperbolic space, you can have infinite parallel lines all intersecting at a single point? Like all possible versions of us, all those parallel lives where I loved you and couldn’t say it, suddenly converging in this moment, in this car, with your hand in mine.”
Bobby pulls the Camaro up to the Hawthorn Inn’s front entrance, its Victorian facade illuminated by a single lantern against the darkening sky. He jumps out and rushes to open Alicia’s door, pulling her close as they hurry through the creaking porch and into the cozy lobby. Alicia’s teeth chatter from the cold, but she feels a warmth spreading through her chest as Bobby wraps an arm around her shoulders, guiding her to the ancient check-in desk. “Room for one night, please,” he says to the elderly caretaker, “for me and my wife.” The old man nods knowingly, handing over a brass key. Alicia’s heart skips a beat at the word “wife,” a secret truth finally spoken aloud. Hand in hand, they ascend the narrow staircase.
Bobby turns the brass key in the lock, and the door swings open to reveal a cozy guest room bathed in the soft glow of a bedside lamp. Alicia steps inside, her eyes taking in the faded floral wallpaper and antique furniture that seem to whisper tales of a bygone era. She runs her fingers along the carved claw feet of the bed, marveling at the intricate craftsmanship. Bobby follows close behind, his hand brushing against Alicia’s lower back in a gesture that feels both familiar and newly charged with longing. As he closes the door, the sound of the latch clicking into place seems to seal them off from the rest of the world.
Alicia Western moves slowly into the center of the room, her fingers trailing along the tarnished mirror of the vanity as she takes in every detail of their sanctuary. Her eyes linger on the bed before turning back to Bobby.
“Remember those stories about Romanian monasteries built into cliff faces? Places that seemed to defy gravity and logic? That’s what this feels like – a pocket universe suspended between what was and what will be. When I was planning to die in those woods, I thought about how cold feels like burning after a while. How pain becomes its own inverse. But this… this warmth between us… it’s like finding the square root of negative one. Bobby, I don’t want to dance yet. I just want to stand here and prove to myself that this is real. That you’re real. That we’ve found our non-Euclidean space where parallel lives can intersect.”
Bobby approaches Alicia and gently begins to unbutton her winter coat, each click of the buttons echoing in the quiet room. As the coat falls open, he sees the white dress beneath, a chilling reminder of his dream and the truth of her attempt at self-annihilation. With a shaky breath, Bobby shrugs off his own jacket, letting it pool at his feet. He pulls Alicia into his arms, cradling her against his chest as he nuzzles his face into her neck. He can feel her heart fluttering against his skin, a steady rhythm that assures him she is alive, here, in his arms, defying the odds and the laws of a universe that tried to keep them apart.
Alicia trembles slightly as Bobby holds her. She catches their reflection in the tarnished mirror: two silhouettes merging in the lamp’s dim glow.
“The air in here tastes like old equations, Bobby. Like theorems written in dust. Do you know what’s beautiful about non-commutative algebra? When you multiply two elements, their order matters. Like us – we had to experience everything in exactly the right sequence to reach this moment. If we’d tried this even a month ago, the variables wouldn’t have aligned. But now… now we’re like a perfect proof. Did you feel how cold I was in those woods? Like absolute zero, the theoretical point where all molecular motion stops. But I was found before I could reach that limit. Your body against mine now – it’s creating heat like fusion, like stars being born. The doctors at Stella Maris would say this is madness, but they never understood that madness has its own elegant mathematics. Its own inviolable laws. When I was fourteen, outside the Indian Rock, you wouldn’t kiss me properly because, as you told me yesterday, I was too young. Now we’re like paired electrons – opposite spins in perfect quantum entanglement. No matter how far apart we are, we’ll always affect each other’s state. Hold me tighter, Bobby. I want to feel the weight of reality pressing against us, proving we exist in the same space at the same time.”
Bobby runs his fingers along Alicia’s scalp as he holds her tight, swaying slightly on his feet.
“What did you think about, Alicia, back when you sat in the frozen woods to die? What thoughts crossed your mind while you waited there alone for the cold to take you?”
She presses her face into Bobby’s chest, her fingers curling into his shirt as if anchoring herself to reality. Her voice emerges muffled but clear, carrying the weight of mathematical certainty.
“I thought about the thermodynamics of dying, Bobby. The precise rate at which my body heat would dissipate into the surrounding air. The way entropy always increases in an isolated system. I calculated how many minutes it would take before my core temperature dropped below the threshold for consciousness. But mostly… mostly I thought about you. About that summer we spent dancing at the Indian Rock, about the way you’d play mandolin with the band while I twirled in my floozy dress. I thought about how in quantum mechanics, observing a system changes its state – and I wondered if my death would somehow alter your comatose state, like entangled particles affecting each other across impossible distances. I even derived an equation for it, there in the snow. Something beautiful and completely insane about the relationship between your consciousness and my existence. The numbers said you’d never wake up, that the probability approached absolute zero. But here you are, defying my calculations, proving that sometimes love is stronger than mathematics. I think Dr. Marcus Hall understood this better than any of my therapists – that the only way to solve an impossible equation is to punch through it, to break the rules that make it impossible in the first place.”
Bobby’s arms tighten around Alicia as they sway gently, their bodies pressed together in a desperate attempt to erase the distance that once separated them. Their movements are slow and tentative, as if afraid that any sudden motion might shatter the fragile reality they’ve found. Alicia’s hands clutch at his back, her fingers digging into the fabric of his shirt. Their eyes meet, a silent exchange of relief for the present and sorrow for the past, while the radiator’s faint hiss fills the room like a quiet symphony. In this moment, there is no need for music or words.
The room seems to hold its breath. As their bodies sway gently, the soft glow from the bedside lamp casts a warm halo around them, creating an intimate bubble that shuts out the cold, dark world beyond the window.
“Bobby, I will never love anyone but you. I knew it even as a girl. That made the world so perilous. I feared the moment you would disappear from my sight. I used to walk those dark country roads at night thinking about non-Euclidean geometry, about spaces where parallel lines could meet. Do you remember that summer night when you played ‘Pretty Polly’ on the mandolin at the Moonlight Diner? I was wearing that red dress, the one that made me look like a floozy, and I wanted you to take me right there on the hood of your car. The doctors said my desires were pathological. When I was freezing in those woods, I thought about the heat death of the universe, about entropy always increasing until no useful work can be done. Bobby, make me forget all those nights I walked the dark roads alone.”
Author’s note: I started rereading The Passenger. I feel that’s something I have to do. I had completely forgotten that it opens with a description of the moment when Alicia’s corpse was found. I read recently that McCarthy had been working on this novel for fifty fucking years. Haunted by her for half of his life.
Pingback: Bringing Alicia Western back to life #3 – The Domains of the Emperor Owl
Pingback: Life update (12/28/2024) – The Domains of the Emperor Owl
Pingback: Bringing Alicia Western back to life #5 – The Domains of the Emperor Owl